Continuously opining, intermittently publishing.
10
November

Barbri California

Posted by oshane | Leave a comment at the end of this post.

I’ve been wanting to do a post-mortem on the bar review course I took for California this summer with Barbri.

Sufficiency of the Materials
Overall, the course was helpful. I took Barbri’s mobile course, which allowed me to watch videos and study from home. Because California is a large national market of bar applicants looking for assistance in preparation for the exam, most of the substantive lectures were very good. The multistate bar examination (MBE) preparatory materials (the MBE is the 200-question multiple choice test that 48 jurisdictions use on the Wednesday of bar exam week) were helpful, because they escalated in difficulty and idiosyncrasy over time. I found Richard Sakai’s pragmatic lectures about how to take the essays generally helpful and Peter Jan Honigsberg’s lectures about the California Performance Test also to be very encouraging and helpful.

That said, the price of the program is too high for the material that is provided. Barbri certainly provides a significant&#151almost overwhelming&#151amount of material to the applicant. To its credit, Barbri makes no assumptions about what the average test taker needs and provides the full gamut of preparatory material so that each student has all the material any applicant might need to study. While I rarely looked at the complete subject matter outlines (instead using the lecture notes or the mini-review), the full outlines allow people who are completely unfamiliar with a subject to study them and feel satisfied they won’t need to do research elsewhere to understand the subject. There were more than enough past essays with model answers to practice and more than enough past performance tests with their own model answers to analyze. The sets of MBE questions were comprehensive.

Value
The irony is that because California is a national market for bar review (i.e., many applicants from all over the country take the test twice a year), the costs Barbri has in producing the materials and paying for the lectures must be subject to economies of scale, particularly when the legal material doesn’t change much from year to year. On one hand, I wonder if the inherent value* of the material is much less than the $4000 price tag of the program. To some extent, the cost of materials plus reasonably moderate double-digit profit** cannot possibly equal $4000. Some of the extra margin is driven by demand for Barbri’s goodwill. That it has been in business for thirty years and that lawyers (or would-be lawyers) are more predisposed to risk avoidance means that law students are routinely more likely to go with the dominant service provider in the market (the apparent tautology that more consumers choose the dominant vendor notwithstanding).

Moreover&#151and I think it was Sakai or Honigsberg that implied as much in one of their lectures&#151California graders have come to expect that essays and performance tests have the formats that Barbri recommends applicants use, simply because (a) so many Barbri students establish a modal “average” for what a 60- or 65-mean scored essay should look like; and (b) many graders themselves used Barbri to prepare for the California Bar Exam when they took it. Thus, Barbri has established a quasi-virtuous cycle with the California bar exam graders and its own students. Students take Barbri because it can claim a higher-than-average pass rate for the California Bar Exam. Some of that incremental difference is likely driven by the fact that graders subconsciously expect essays on the whole to look like Barbri recommends, potentially leading to more satisfactory scores for Barbri students.

Thus, the profit margins that California Barbri students pay are attributable both to its historical presence (goodwill) in the market and a virtuous cycle.

I wonder&#151at least for self-motivated home studiers&#151whether it would be less costly and equally as effective to get hold of written California Barbri essay materials in the secondary market (thanks to the First Sale Doctrine***, eBay, and Amazon) and simply practice writing essays that look similar to Barbri essays. On the other hand, if one is simply just perusing the Barbri materials without paying for the service, it is arguably more worthwhile simply to look at the selected answers California releases with past exams for a more direct understanding of what graders are looking for.

Undoubtedly, part of the value Barbri provides is in the feedback loop it provides for its students. Barbri, because of its size and customer base, can scale MBE practice question scores relative to other Barbri students, which provides, assuming its MBE questions on average represent the MBE questions created by the National Conference of Bar Examiners, an effective sample size for low-error rate comparison between other California test takers and a good guess at what a student’s MBE score will look like.

The Other Part of the Feedback Loop:
Essay Grading

Barbri also grades its students’ essays. This is the most value-lacking part of the course. I’ve heard from Barbri students in other jurisdictions that the essay grading in those places is helpful and a fairly accurate representation of the grading that will be done by actual bar examiners.

Not so in California. Barbri graders routinely grade practice essays with an élan for doom. The scores students receive are typically very low, particularly at the beginning of the course, and sometimes at the end. No one really knows why but a consensus is that that Barbri is attempting to bootcamp its students into realizing that the California graders will not treat graciously a poorly written essay. On one hand, that could be commendable tough love. For me, it was nerve-racking and unhelpful. At first, when I received an excessively low grade from Barbri, I crusaded to shore my bar exam essay writing skills up. And then when more low scores were returned to me, I became discouraged. It wasn’t until I read about students literally copying model answers word for word, submitting them as experiments, and still receiving failing grades, that I realized that Barbri was intentionally deflating scores to impel its students to work harder.

At one point, I received a 45 on an essay. I had made some mistakes, but nothing seemingly major. When I compared my essay to the grading rubric, I realized the grading system was a farce. A Barbri 45 indicates that the essay had not identified one major issue. In fact, in my essay, I had identified all but one minor issue. The grading was self-referentially incoherent as compared to the standards.

I do not doubt that for some students, the Stick can be a very motivating incentive to try harder and do better as opposed to the Carrot. For me&#151as I am already a self-motivated, self-starting student&#151it was simply discouraging. All I wanted was honest feedback. If an essay truly deserved a 45, then I wanted to hear it. At one point, I wrote an essay that I thought was akin to a 75, and I think I received a 65. At that point, my disagreement with Barbri would have been debatable, if not pointless. 65 is a passing grade for an essay on the California Bar Exam, and if in real life the essay was actually a 75, then telling me I received a 65 might have been marginally helpful to keep me from complacency without harming my own developing self-heuristic for what way of writing would help me pass a real essay question.

But when Barbri’s eagerness to keep its students from prosaic complacency leads them to fail practice essays by a wide margin when the essay may have been borderline or even a fair pass, Barbri loses its effectiveness as a preparatory tool. This also doesn’t comport with Barbri’s goodnatured cheerleading and its continual reminders that we should prepare enough, but just enough, to pass. It was difficult for me to simply aim for a barely passing grade but, my own fastidiousness for excellence aside, the fact that Barbri was proclaiming we should do “just enough” as contrasted to its graders failing essays that were objectively just good enough to pass, reduced the utility, consistency, and clarity of the process overall.

Conclusion
We find out in eight days whether those of us who took the July 2011 California Bar Examination passed. I wanted to write my thoughts about the Barbri process before I found out, so that my opinion would not be colored by whether I passed the exam. That said, if I am honest with myself, good news next Friday will probably wash away the bad aftertaste in my mouth left by Barbri’s wonky practice essay grading system.

Overall, I found the program effective&#151maybe not perfectly tuned to the California Bar Exam like some of the smaller boutique tutoring programs in California may be&#151but sufficient. I still question whether the price tag is worth it. I certainly think $2000 would be an outstanding value. At $4000, students enter the realm of prices for private tutoring ($5000+), and I wonder if paying another $1000 would have made for a better, more productive, or more effective experience overall. Barbri should lower its prices, but it still seemed to provide a relatively good, though not perfect, value.


Footnotes
* Whatever this means. Value is always best calculated by what a willing buyer pays a willing seller. Thus, I don’t believe the $4000 price comprises just the value of the books and lectures, but also includes a host of intangibles. See supra.

** I do not begrudge high profits and do not really believe in the notion of “reasonable” profits as some sort of moral limiting factor on profit&#151that doesn’t mean I want (as a self-interested actor) to pay more than some arbitrarily low percentage of profit, even though I may still choose to do so anyway. Obviously there are comparative reverse inequalities of value at work. Such is the nature of free-market demand.

*** No doubt Barbri and zealous IP attorneys would argue the First Sale Doctrine does not apply to a set of “leased” books, but the designation of the books as under a lease is arguable, especially given the fact that there is an inherent liquidated damages provision in the Barbri agreement in case one does not return the books, stipulating he loses his book deposit. This, among other factors, makes the part of the transaction having to do with the written books look like a sale.

Full disclosure: I returned my California Barbri materials to Barbri per the face of my agreement with Barbri and received the deposit back.

173 Responses to “Barbri California”

  1. <The Best Kitesurfing Spot in Algarve
    Located in the beautiful coastal town of Lagos, Portugal, Algarve Kite Center is renowned as the best kitesurfing spot in the Algarve region. With its ideal wind conditions, stunning beaches, and clear blue waters, this spot offers the perfect setting for an exhilarating kitesurfing adventure.

    Whether you're a beginner or an experienced kitesurfer, Algarve Kite Center has something to offer for everyone. The spot is suitable for all skill levels, making it a popular choice among kitesurfing enthusiasts from around the world.

    Immerse yourself in the breathtaking natural beauty of the Algarve while enjoying the thrill of kitesurfing at this top-notch spot. Prepare to be amazed by the incredible views and adrenaline-pumping rides that await you at Algarve Kite Center. kiteschool Portugal

  2. Publicbith says:

    Bitcoin mixer, или миксер биткоина, является сервисом, который предназначен для смешивания биткоинов от разных пользователей с целью сокрытия истории транзакций. Эти сервисы используются для увеличения приватности и безопасности транзакций с биткоинами, путем разрыва связей между адресами отправителя и получателя.
    Mixer bitcoin
    Принцип работы Bitcoin mixer’ов заключается в том, что они берут биткоины от разных пользователей, перемешивают их в общем пуле, а затем возвращают обратно пользователям. Этот процесс затрудняет возможность проследить происхождение биткоинов, поскольку теперь они смешаны с биткоинами других пользователей.

  3. Kguaoowak says:

    I was in reality itching to get some wager some money on some sports matches that are happening right now. I wanted to disillusion admit you guys be familiar with that I did find what I weigh to be the a-one plat in the USA.
    If you destitution to get in on the engagement, authenticate it out-moded: best casino

  4. ManuelChoms says:

    Do you need reviews on google, reviews on voting sites, do you need someone to create gmail accounts, do you want to increase the views of your youtube video, or do you need people to perform small tasks on the Internet, and much more you can solve through the site https://aviso.bz/?r=filosof20063

  5. ScottMat says:

    кстанди цена – тирзепатид купить, моунжаро купить

  6. Walterwix says:

    ozempic инструкция +по применению +на русском – манджаро купить тирзепатид, mounjaro купить +в дубае

  7. Donaldper says:

    Че, компаньон! Ты ищешь дельную инфу про то, зачем тебе копаться на нашем сайте? Окей, держи фишку!

    Слушай, здесь у нас не просто вебсайт, это кладезь познаний, где тебе предоставляется возможность выдавить всю соковитую инфу, собственно что лишь только захочешь! Эй, ну да мы как те уличные братки, представляешь ли, всегда подскажем, как спасти тебя из каждой капусты.

    https://diasporaconnect.md/questions/89a8f04e-c42f-11ee-980b-901b0e9325fd

    Тут на любом углу – инструкции, советы, рецепты, ну да собственно что угодно! Не имеет никакого значения, че ты штудируешь – кулинарию, программирование, фитнес либо философию. У нас есть все варианты, как в кармане у грамотного философа.

    А, и как мы запямытовали сказать, дружище, наш сайт это не столько информация, это и связь с реальными профи! Здесь ты можешь задавать свои вопросы, делиться средствами находками, обсуждать важные темы с такими же заинтересованными братками, как ты.

    И не теряй время, выделяй, заскакивай к нам на вебсайт и окунись в мир познаний и общения, кот-ый мы для тебя приготовили! Ведь кто знает, имеет возможность, здесь для тебя раскроются двери в свежую жизнь, как в фильмах!

  8. Installing a walkout basement door: Enhance accessibility and functionality with professional installation of a walkout basement door by Aspectmontage Inc. Installing a walkout basement door

  9. Davidrob says:

    оземпик +будет ли – аземпик инструкция +по применению, мунджаро фото

  10. Richardanani says:

    игра gates of olympus – gates of olympus game, играть в слоты gates of olympus

  11. dimkainmd says:

    В поисках идеального кондиционера в Кишиневе, столице Молдовы, вам доступно множество вариантов. Город обладает развитой инфраструктурой и многочисленными магазинами, предлагающими широкий выбор кондиционеров различных марок и моделей. Для удобства выбора и покупки, рассмотрим несколько популярных вариантов:

    Специализированные магазины по продаже бытовой техники: В Кишиневе существует множество магазинов, специализирующихся на продаже бытовой техники, включая кондиционеры. Здесь вы сможете получить профессиональную консультацию от продавцов и выбрать подходящий кондиционер для ваших потребностей.

    Интернет-магазины: В сети интернет также предоставляется широкий выбор кондиционеров с возможностью сравнения характеристик и цен. Многие интернет-магазины осуществляют доставку в Кишинев, что делает процесс покупки более удобным.

    Специализированные магазины по климатической технике: В городе действуют магазины, специализирующиеся исключительно на климатической технике. Здесь вы найдете большой ассортимент кондиционеров различных типов – от оконных до сплит-систем.

    Большие розничные сети: Некоторые крупные розничные сети также предлагают разнообразные варианты кондиционеров. Эти магазины часто предоставляют гарантии на продукцию и могут предложить дополнительные услуги, такие как монтаж и обслуживание.

    Перед покупкой рекомендуется провести небольшое исследование рынка, сравнить цены и отзывы о конкретных моделях. Независимо от выбранного варианта, важно обратить внимание на квалификацию продавцов и гарантии, предоставляемые на приобретаемое оборудование.
    https://conditioner.md/

  12. WilliamLum says:

    оземпик препарат инструкция – +от диабета оземпик, оземпик казахстан

  13. Robertbuisa says:

    kraken ссылка тор – kraken ссылка тор, ссылка на кракен тор

  14. Jamesbiamp says:

    Смешно Могучая Лиза
    Могучая Лиза

  15. Located in the beautiful coastal town of Lagos, Portugal, Algarve Kite Center is renowned as the best kitesurfing spot in the Algarve region. With its ideal wind conditions, stunning beaches, and clear blue waters, this spot offers the perfect setting for an exhilarating kitesurfing adventure.

    Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced kitesurfer, Algarve Kite Center has something to offer for everyone. The spot is suitable for all skill levels, making it a popular choice among kitesurfing enthusiasts from around the world.

    Immerse yourself in the breathtaking natural beauty of the Algarve while enjoying the thrill of kitesurfing at this top-notch spot. Prepare to be amazed by the incredible views and adrenaline-pumping rides that await you at Algarve Kite Center.
    Kitesurfing Lagos

  16. Stanleysmita says:

    Ознакомьтесь с большим ассортиментом отделочных материалов оптом на нашем сайте. Доставка гарантия качества по выгодным ценам оптом https://rolaks.com/

  17. |
    Over past 10 years, in winter, number of kiters in Algarve has increased by 300%, this was influenced by the pandemic, housing prices, climate, and of course remote work, which allows you to live anywhere.

  18. <The Best Kitesurfing Spot in Algarve
    Located in the beautiful coastal town of Lagos, Portugal, Algarve Kite Center is renowned as the best kitesurfing spot in the Algarve region. With its ideal wind conditions, stunning beaches, and clear blue waters, this spot offers the perfect setting for an exhilarating kitesurfing adventure.

    Whether you're a beginner or an experienced kitesurfer, Algarve Kite Center has something to offer for everyone. The spot is suitable for all skill levels, making it a popular choice among kitesurfing enthusiasts from around the world.

    Immerse yourself in the breathtaking natural beauty of the Algarve while enjoying the thrill of kitesurfing at this top-notch spot. Prepare to be amazed by the incredible views and adrenaline-pumping rides that await you at Algarve Kite Center.
    Kitesurfing Algarve

  19. Ernestobax says:

    Бизнесмен Андрей Кнауб хорошо известен как предприниматель и трейдер в сфере нефтепереработки. Он более 25 лет был частью крупнейших отраслевых компаний, реализовал множество благотворительных и социальных проектов кнауб андрей артурович

Leave a Reply to oshane